Pouvez vous me donner des exemples sur la terre où l'énergie du soleil contribu à diminuer l'entropie d'un système ouvert. Un exemple où la matière organique s'agglomère et forme une quelconque forme de réseau ordonné complexe hautement énergétique, telle une simple protéine?
Puisque le contexte de ce débat concerne l'origine de la vie, toute matière vivante est exclut.
“He makes it appears as though crystals and highly ordered organic molecules belong to the same class, when in fact they do not. When a crystal is broken up, the smaller crystals are physically and chemically identical to the original. This is never observed with organic molecules ; when the original molecule is split up, lesser molecules appear, and part of the original information is lost. To ignore such FUNDAMENTAL differences in an effort to arrive at some general overview or law is to create a FALSE overview, a pseudolaw.”
“… to say that “there is an obvious tendency of nature from disorder to order and organisation” and to advance this idea to a “fourth law” is to misunderstand completely and to compromise all of thermodynamics”
“ … Yet, under ordinary conditions, no complex organic molecule can ever from spontaneously but will rather disintegrate, in agreement with the second law. Indeed, the more complex it is, the more unstable it is, and the more assured, sooner or later, is its disintegration. Photosynthesis and all life processes, and life itself, despite confused or deliberately confusing language, cannot yet be understood in terms of thermodynamics or any other exact science.”
Stravropoulos, Georges P. American Scientist “The Frontier and Limits of Science” juillet 1977, Vol 65, pp. 674-676.
|