A22 à A24+B22 à B26

Posté par Jules , Oct 15,2002,18:54

re!

Tes propositions:

A22 : Il y a plusieurs rapports de témoignages concernant le Yéti et le monstre du Loch Ness.
A23 : Le Yeti et le monstre du Loch Ness n'existent pas.
A24 : Entre les auteurs de (21) et de (25) de http://www.lejardindeslivres.com/04encyc1.htm#sdfootnote8sym seul le second dit "j'ai vu".

A22= 100% A23: 80% A24: 99%

Juste un commentaire sur A23: l'existence du Yéti me parait plus crédible que celle du monstre du Loch Ness dont la lac a été sondé. j'aurais mis A'23 Yeti: 70% et A"23 Ness: 99%

Hmmm, tu évalues ma "pensée magique"?
A moi:

B22:"s'il existe, le yéti est certainement un grand singe"

B23: "Aucun témoignage à propos du monstre du Loch Ness ne prétend l'avoir vu à moins de 3 mètres."

B24: Dans le temoignage suivant de "lévitation mouvante" à Garabandal, issu de http://www.garabandal.co.za/book_testimonials.htm#Testimony%20of%20Dr.%20Ricardo%20Puncernau , le témoin dit "j'ai vu" et "j'ai entendu"

Dr. Percernau’s Story
[...]On one occasion I saw the 'visionaries' facing the closed doors of the little village church. They remained fixed there as if they were asking permission to enter. Then without losing their 'second state' they turned around and extended their arms in the form of a cross. “They’re going to fly. They’re going to fly,” I heard the people around the whisper. This seemed a little ridiculous to me. But to my astonishment, they began to race, their arms extended, throughout the streets of the village.
It was very strange. They gave me the impression of scarcely moving, flying a bit, as in a slow motion film pseudo-levitation; but the speed was unbelievable, so much so, that the young people of the village, with all the vigour of youth, were not able to catch up with them in spite of exerted efforts. After crossing the entire village they went back to a normal pace and a little later left their 'second state' smiling.[...]

B25: l'écrivain Ramon Perez a receuilli ces témoignages avec rigueur et esprit critique

B26: le texte précédent et le témoignage de l'abbé ramon etc https://forum-sceptique.com/archives/36105.html#36105 proviennent de deux sources différentes.

Mes évaluations: A22=99% B23=99% B24=100% B25=95% B26=100%

voila, à toi.

Suivi

B22 à B26 + A25 à A27 --- Denis (Tue, Oct 15, 2002, 22:26:10) (14 reads) (1330 bytes) +1
- A25 à A27+B27 à B31 --- Jules (Wed, Oct 16, 2002, 08:36:05) (12 reads) (2666 bytes) +1
  - B27 à B31 + A28 à A30 --- Denis (Wed, Oct 16, 2002, 13:43:34) (15 reads) (3511 bytes) +1
    - A28 à A30+B32 à B34 --- Jules (Thu, Oct 17, 2002, 08:15:33) (12 reads) (1622 bytes) +1
      - B32 à B34 + A31 à A35 --- Denis (Thu, Oct 17, 2002, 13:37:57) (12 reads) (3725 bytes) +1
        
        A31 à A35+B35 --- Jules (Thu, Oct 17, 2002, 16:59:00) (13 reads) (948 bytes) +1
        
        B35 + A36 --- Denis (Thu, Oct 17, 2002, 21:42:16) (11 reads) (1688 bytes) +1
        
        A36+B36àB37 --- Jules (Fri, Oct 18, 2002, 17:58:15) (6 reads) (563 bytes) +1
        
        B36 et B37 + A37 à A39 --- Denis (Sat, Oct 19, 2002, 00:56:16) (9 reads) (1378 bytes) +1
        
        A37 à A39 + B38 à B39 --- Jules (Sat, Oct 19, 2002, 19:22:14) (7 reads) (873 bytes) +1
        
        B38 à B39 + A40 à A42 --- Denis (Sat, Oct 19, 2002, 20:50:59) (6 reads) (1720 bytes) +1
        
        A40 à A42+ B40 à B42 --- Jules (Sun, Oct 20, 2002, 12:20:17) (13 reads) (2023 bytes) +2
        
        B41 + A45 à A49 --- Denis (Tue, Oct 22, 2002, 19:52:36) (8 reads) (2428 bytes) +1
        
        A45 à A49+ B43àB46 --- Jules (Wed, Oct 23, 2002, 09:28:37) (7 reads) (2140 bytes) +1
        
        B43 à B46 + A50 à A56 --- Denis (Thu, Oct 24, 2002, 00:01:20) (6 reads) (5047 bytes)
        
        B40 à B42 + --- Denis (Mon, Oct 21, 2002, 04:25:28) (10 reads) (2538 bytes)